The 5 Best Fence Companies in Fishers

In Fishers, a new fence usually means HOA approval, marked utility lines and sometimes a permit, so the right company handles the paperwork as well as the posts. These five independent fence companies serve Fishers and have strong Google reviews. For each one, we read the recent reviews and wrote down what people actually say, good and bad.

Our 5 picks at a glance

  1. Draper Fence & Rail Co.: custom wood fences and tricky permits
  2. BlueBird Fence: hands-off HOA and permit paperwork
  3. Hoplite Fencing: a fast, budget-friendly install
  4. North Indy Fence, Deck & Rail: railings, decks and repairs
  5. Amerifence (Westfield): one-day installs from a long-running family firm

Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.

1. Draper Fence & Rail Co.

★ 4.9 Google (373 reviews)5.0 Yelp (11 reviews)BBB A+, accredited

Best for custom wood fences and tricky permits

What reviewers say: Reviewers say Draper kept in touch from quote to install and helped line up permits, HOA approval and utility marking. Cedar privacy and scalloped picket fences, aluminum railings and gates all come up, and big jobs often go in within a day or two. Several picked Draper after comparing three or more quotes.

Good to know: Expect a wait: reviewers mention a few weeks between signing and install. A couple also needed a gate adjusted after the job, which the crew came back to fix.

  • Serving the Indianapolis area since 2014, with a lifetime craftsmanship warranty and free in-person estimates (per its website)
  • Wood, vinyl, aluminum and chain link fences, gates and railings, residential and commercial
  • Based on Kingman Dr on the Indianapolis northeast side; its website lists Fishers among the areas it serves

2. BlueBird Fence

★ 4.8 Google (642 reviews)4.6 Yelp (9 reviews)BBB A+, accredited

Best for hands-off HOA and permit paperwork

What reviewers say: The paperwork is the big theme: reviewers say BlueBird handled the HOA approval, the city permit and the utility marking for them. People also mention steady updates on the schedule, a whole fence finished in one day, and a price that beat the other local quotes they got.

  • Wood, aluminum and chain link fences and gates
  • Based on 3rd Ave SW in Carmel

3. Hoplite Fencing

★ 4.8 Google (208 reviews)3.6 Yelp (8 reviews)BBB profile, not accredited

Best for a fast, budget-friendly install

What reviewers say: Price and speed come up again and again: reviewers say Hoplite gave the best estimate they got and tore out the old fence and put up the new one in a day or two. Many reviewers name Jeremie, saying he was quick to respond, easy to reach and kept them posted. Cedar privacy fences, vinyl and chain link all show up.

  • Veteran-owned (per its Facebook page, and several reviewers mention it)
  • New fences, replacements and repairs in cedar, vinyl and chain link; reviewers mention steel posts on wood fences
  • Based on Kasteel Way on the Indianapolis northeast side (46250)

4. North Indy Fence, Deck & Rail

★ 4.7 Google (279 reviews)Yelp: no rating we could confirmBBB accredited (grade not shown)

Best for railings, decks and repairs

What reviewers say: A lot of these reviews are about railings: porch and step handrails, aluminum porch railings and a long railing down a steep walkout. Reviewers also mention decks, chain link repairs after storm damage, a driveway gate operator, and fixing a gate another builder couldn’t. People say the owner walks them through options and the crews explain the work and clean up.

Good to know: One reviewer said communication before the job was slow until they followed up.

  • Fences, gates and gate operators, decks, and porch and stair railings; also repairs on fences it didn’t build
  • BBB accredited since 2025 (BBB)
  • Showroom on Conner St (State Road 32) in Noblesville

5. Amerifence (Westfield)

★ 4.8 Google (57 reviews)3.0 Yelp (70 reviews, company-wide listing)BBB A+, accredited

Best for one-day installs from a long-running family firm

What reviewers say: One-day installs are the main theme, including one where the old fence came out and the new one went in within seven hours. Reviewers also praise the crews for straight, well-aligned fence lines and for cleaning up, and a couple say the salesperson explained the process and thought through the fence line with them up front.

Good to know: Its Yelp rating, which covers the whole company, is much lower than this office’s Google rating.

  • Fourth-generation, family-owned company with more than 95 years in fence installation (per its website)
  • Aluminum, cedar and vinyl fences
  • This office is on Maple St in downtown Westfield, and it’s open Saturday mornings (Google lists 8 a.m. to noon)

How we picked

  • We started with the fence companies that show up on Google Maps for Fishers searches, then kept the ones based in Hamilton County or on the Indianapolis northeast side.
  • To make the list, a company had to be independent and locally owned (no national franchises), rated 4.7 or higher on Google with at least 50 reviews, and have no BBB grade below A- if it has a BBB profile. We left out pet-containment and invisible-fence dealers.
  • We ordered them by Google rating adjusted for review count, so a 4.8 from 600 people counts for more than a 5.0 from 12. (We blend each rating with 100 reviews at 4.5 stars, so small samples don’t jump to the top.)
  • We read about 30 recent Google reviews for each company and summarized the themes that came up more than once. One-off complaints aren’t counted as themes.
  • Ratings and review counts were checked on November 16, 2026. They change daily, so click through for today’s numbers. We recheck this list every few months.

Before you hire any fence company

  • Check your HOA rules first. Many Fishers neighborhoods limit fence height, style and color, and want approval before work starts.
  • Ask whether your project needs a permit from the City of Fishers, and whether the company will pull it.
  • Make sure utility lines get marked before anyone digs. In Indiana that’s a free call to 811, and good fence companies set it up for you.
  • Know where your property line is. If you’re not sure, a survey or your plat map can save a fight with a neighbor later.
  • Get the price, materials, post type and gate details in writing, and ask about the deposit and any card fees.
  • Ask what the warranty covers and for how long, especially for gates, which several reviewers needed adjusted after the install.

Questions people ask

Will a fence company handle my HOA approval and permit?

Many will. Reviewers say BlueBird Fence and Draper Fence & Rail took care of HOA approval, permits and utility marking for them. Hoplite and Amerifence reviewers also describe help meeting HOA rules. Ask up front so you know what’s included.

How long does it take to get a fence installed?

The install itself is fast: reviewers of all five companies describe fences going in within a day or two. The wait before that is longer. Draper and Amerifence reviewers mention about three weeks from signing to install, and Hoplite reviewers say it can be a few weeks out in busy season.

Why isn’t my favorite fence company on the list?

It may not have met one of our cutoffs (4.7+ on Google with 50+ reviews, locally owned, no BBB grade below A-), or we may have missed it. Tell us about it using the link below, and we’ll look at it when we recheck the list.

Run a fence company in Fishers? Tell us about your business. Getting on this list is free and follows the rules above. Separately, you can become the labeled local expert behind one of our guides.