The 5 Best Roofers in Fishers

After a hailstorm, roofers seem to appear on every street in Fishers. The ones worth calling will show you photos of the damage, explain the insurance process plainly, and still answer the phone after the job is done. These are five local, independent roofing companies with strong Google reviews, and for each one we read the recent reviews and wrote down what people actually say.

Our 5 picks at a glance

  1. Weathertight Roofing: a Fishers roofer for storm claims and gutters
  2. OpenBox Roofing: a clear walk-through with no surprise fees
  3. Rojas Roofing: small repairs as well as full roofs
  4. 3 Kings Roofing and Construction: an owner who stays on the job
  5. Blue Ladder Roofing: hail damage and insurance paperwork

Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.

1. Weathertight Roofing

★ 5.0 Google (357 reviews)5.0 Yelp (3 reviews)BBB A+, accredited

Best for a Fishers roofer for storm claims and gutters

What reviewers say: Reviewers say the team helped them work with their insurance company and kept them updated from start to finish. Fair pricing comes up often, including one reviewer whose bill was well under another company’s quote. People also mention careful cleanup (one crew did an extra nail sweep for the family dog), quick repairs without pressure to do more, and new gutters.

  • Roof repairs and replacements, gutters and gutter guards, siding; reviewers also mention windows
  • Based in Fishers on South St; its website also lists Monticello and Muncie
  • Google lists it as open 24 hours

2. OpenBox Roofing

★ 5.0 Google (280 reviews)5.0 Yelp (2 reviews)BBB A+, accredited

Best for a clear walk-through with no surprise fees

What reviewers say: Many reviews name the same few staff members and say they explained each step and answered questions patiently. Reviewers mention no hidden fees, help getting insurance to cover a replacement, and a fix for leaks another roofer had left behind on a three-year-old roof. Crews show up on time and clean up when they’re done.

Good to know: A lot of its recent reviews are very short, so read a few of the longer ones before you decide. Google lists daytime hours (8 a.m. to 5 p.m.).

  • Locally owned (per its Facebook page); Tom Sovich is president, in business since 2021 (BBB)
  • Roof replacement and repair, storm damage insurance claims, siding
  • Based on Castleway Dr on the northeast side of Indianapolis; Google lists Fishers, Geist, Carmel, Noblesville and McCordsville among its service areas

3. Rojas Roofing

★ 5.0 Google (262 reviews)Yelp: no listing we could confirmBBB A+, accredited

Best for small repairs as well as full roofs

What reviewers say: Reviewers like that Rojas takes small jobs: a few loose shingles after a storm, a downspout, wind damage repaired without pushing a full replacement. For bigger jobs, they describe help with the insurance company, steady updates and good cleanup. Owner Freddy Rojas and estimator Chad come up by name again and again, and several people are repeat customers.

Good to know: Google lists weekday hours only (Mon–Fri 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.).

  • Owned by Freddy Rojas, according to reviewers; a member of the Noblesville Chamber of Commerce (per its website)
  • Residential and commercial roofing, storm damage repair, gutters, siding, exterior painting
  • Based in Noblesville on Pleasant St; its website has a page for Fishers homeowners

4. 3 Kings Roofing and Construction

★ 5.0 Google (200 reviews)4.0 Yelp (4 reviews)BBB A+, accredited

Best for an owner who stays on the job

What reviewers say: Nearly every review mentions Paul, the owner, and his communication from the first estimate through the final check. Reviewers say the work matched the quote, the price was competitive (one said it beat every other bid), and he still answers when something needs attention later. Full tear-offs with gutters, a leak and skylight fixed the next day, and one-day roof replacements all come up.

  • Co-owned by Paul and Nancee Crouse, in business since 2009 (BBB); veteran-owned (per its website)
  • Roof replacement and repair, gutters, siding
  • Based in Fishers on Trade Center Dr; Google lists it as open 24 hours

5. Blue Ladder Roofing

★ 4.8 Google (418 reviews)Yelp: no rating we could confirmBBB A+, accredited

Best for hail damage and insurance paperwork

What reviewers say: Hail and storm damage claims make up much of the reviews. People say the inspectors took photos, walked them through the damage, and worked with their insurance company, in one case getting a full replacement approved after the insurer wanted only a repair. Reviewers also call the reps professional and easy to talk to.

Good to know: A couple of reviewers first met a rep who came by their neighborhood after a storm, and one called that storm chasing. Another said follow-up on a problem after installation was slow. Get the scope in writing and ask who to call after the job.

  • Owned by Austin Chastain, in business since 2019 (BBB)
  • Roof inspections and replacement, storm damage repair, gutters
  • Based in Fishers on Promise Creek Ln

How we picked

  • We started with the roofing companies that show up on Google Maps for Fishers searches. Each one had to be based in Fishers or nearby in Hamilton County or the northeast side, and clearly serve Fishers through a Google service area or its own website.
  • To make the list, a company had to be independent and locally owned (no national franchises), rated 4.7 or higher on Google with at least 50 reviews, and have no BBB grade below A- if it has a BBB profile. We also left off a highly rated listing whose recent reviews were almost all for storm door installs rather than roofing.
  • We ordered them by Google rating adjusted for review count, so a 4.9 from 400 people counts for more than a 5.0 from 20. (We blend each rating with 100 reviews at 4.5 stars, so small samples don’t jump to the top.)
  • We read about 30 recent Google reviews for each company and summarized the themes that came up more than once. One-off complaints aren’t counted as themes.
  • Ratings and review counts were checked on November 16, 2026. They change daily, so click through for today’s numbers. We recheck this list every few months.

Before you hire any roofer

  • Ask for proof of liability and workers’ comp insurance, and check the company’s BBB profile and recent reviews. Indiana doesn’t have a statewide roofing license, so these checks matter more.
  • If someone knocks after a storm, take their card, then get your own inspection from a company you chose. You don’t have to sign anything on the spot.
  • Get the full scope in writing: shingle brand and line, underlayment, flashing, ventilation, gutters and cleanup.
  • Ask whether the job needs a permit and who will pull it. In Fishers, building permits come from the City of Fishers.
  • Ask what the workmanship warranty covers and how long it lasts, separate from the manufacturer’s shingle warranty.

Questions people ask

Will a roofer help with my insurance claim?

Most of the roofers on this list do. Reviewers of Weathertight, OpenBox, Rojas and Blue Ladder describe help documenting damage and working with the insurance company. You still decide what to file, so read your policy and talk to your insurer too.

Do these roofers do small repairs, or only full replacements?

Several do repairs. Rojas reviewers describe fixes for a few loose shingles, a downspout and storm damage, Weathertight reviewers mention quick repairs without pressure to do more, and 3 Kings fixed a leak and skylight the day after a call.

Why isn’t my favorite roofer on the list?

It may not have met one of our cutoffs (4.7+ on Google with 50+ reviews, no BBB grade below A-, locally owned, and based in or clearly serving Fishers), or we may have missed it. Tell us about it using the link below, and we’ll look at it when we recheck the list.

Run a roofing company in Fishers? Tell us about your business. Getting on this list is free and follows the rules above. Separately, you can become the labeled local expert behind one of our guides.