The 7 Best House Painters in Fishers

A good paint job is mostly prep: covering floors, fixing rotted trim, scraping and caulking before any paint goes on. These seven independent painting companies in and around Fishers have strong Google reviews, and for each one we read the recent reviews and wrote down what people actually say, good and bad.

Our 7 picks at a glance

  1. The Painting Edge: painting plus drywall and trim repair
  2. Heritage Painting: help choosing colors
  3. Onit Painting: detailed quotes on bigger exterior jobs
  4. Guy Painting: exteriors with wood rot repair
  5. DutchPopp Painting: owner-quoted jobs and limewashed brick
  6. White’s Painting and Power Washing: power washing and paint from one crew
  7. Bays Painting: kitchen cabinets

Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.

1. The Painting Edge

★ 5.0 Google (396 reviews)5.0 Yelp (16 reviews)BBB A+, accredited

Best for painting plus drywall and trim repair

What reviewers say: The owner, Todd, comes up in almost every review: he gives the quote, helps with color choices and stays easy to reach by text or phone. A lot of jobs go beyond paint, with drywall patches after water damage, trim carpentry, wallpaper removal and cabinet refinishing. Many reviewers are repeat customers, one for more than 20 years.

  • Founded by Todd Cartmel, working in Carmel and Fishers since 1996 (per its website); BBB accredited since 2011 (BBB)
  • Interior and exterior painting, cabinets, drywall repair, trim carpentry, wallpaper removal, staining
  • Based on Rangeline Rd in Carmel

2. Heritage Painting

★ 5.0 Google (294 reviews)3.2 Yelp (5 reviews)BBB A+, accredited

Best for help choosing colors

What reviewers say: Several reviewers mention working with a color consultant before the job, and say the process from estimate to final coat was easy. Clean-up gets a lot of praise, with one reviewer saying the house was cleaner than before. Jobs range from interiors and kitchens to exterior trim, decks, a pole barn and even a warehouse floor.

  • Founded in 2009, owned by two families and veteran and firefighter owned (per its Nextdoor page)
  • Interior, exterior and cabinet painting, decks, and epoxy floors, for homes and businesses
  • This office is on Lantern Rd in Fishers; the company also has Google listings in Carmel and Tipton

3. Onit Painting

★ 4.9 Google (783 reviews)3.8 Yelp (18 reviews)BBB accredited (grade not shown)

Best for detailed quotes on bigger exterior jobs

What reviewers say: Reviewers like the quote: detailed, measured, sometimes with photos of problem spots, so there were no surprises on scope. Exterior jobs with rotted wood replaced first come up often, including on a 33-year-old Fishers home. People describe a project manager who stays in touch and crews that finish on the schedule they were given, and several are repeat customers.

Good to know: Two recent reviewers said they weren’t told up front that crews are subcontracted, and both had problems with exterior finish details. One said the owner stepped in and resolved it. Ask who will do the work.

  • BBB accredited since 2017 (BBB)
  • Interior and exterior painting, wood rot repair, trim, decks, residential and commercial
  • Based on E 87th St near Castleton, on the Indianapolis northeast side

4. Guy Painting

★ 4.9 Google (637 reviews)3.9 Yelp (15 reviews)BBB A+

Best for exteriors with wood rot repair

What reviewers say: Exterior repaints with wood repair are the main theme: rotted cedar trim, siding and soffits replaced, then power washing and paint. Reviewers like the detailed written quote and the chance to talk colors with an expert. Inside, they mention crews covering floors, taking off switch plates and cleaning up, and several have hired the company more than once.

  • Family-owned (per its website)
  • Interior and exterior painting, wood and window repair, deck and pergola staining, concrete coatings; reviewers include a condo community
  • Based on E 82nd St on the Indianapolis northeast side; Google lists Saturday morning office hours

5. DutchPopp Painting

★ 5.0 Google (205 reviews)4.6 Yelp (9 reviews)BBB: no profile we could confirm

Best for owner-quoted jobs and limewashed brick

What reviewers say: Reviewers often say an owner came out to quote the job himself, then a project manager kept them updated through the job. Spotless job sites come up again and again. Work includes whole interiors, exterior trim, vanities and stair spindles, deck and fence staining, and limewashed brick.

Good to know: It books up: two reviewers were scheduled about three weeks to a month out. One reviewer found it about $1,000 higher than two other quotes and still chose it.

  • Firefighter owned and operated (per its Instagram)
  • Interior and exterior painting, cabinets and vanities, limewash, deck and fence staining, rotted wood replacement
  • On S 10th St in Noblesville

6. White’s Painting and Power Washing

★ 4.9 Google (241 reviews)4.9 Yelp (19 reviews)BBB accredited (grade not shown)

Best for power washing and paint from one crew

What reviewers say: Many jobs start with a full house wash and end with fresh trim, gutters or siding paint, and plenty of reviewers hire it just for power washing. Reviewers say the White family is hands-on, with Bob or Bill quoting and checking in on the crew, and that rotted trim boards get replaced before painting. Several call the price fair next to other quotes they got.

  • Family owned (per its Facebook page, and reviewers say so too); BBB accredited since 2015 (BBB)
  • Interior and exterior painting, power and soft washing, trim replacement, kitchen cabinets, metal roof coating
  • Based on Allisonville Rd in Fishers

7. Bays Painting

★ 5.0 Google (106 reviews)Yelp: no rating we could confirmBBB: no profile we could confirm

Best for kitchen cabinets

What reviewers say: Kitchen cabinets dominate the reviews, from two-tone kitchens to a china cabinet, and one reviewer was glad not to have to empty the cabinets first. Reviewers also mention bedrooms, tall living rooms and drywall patches finished in about three days. They say the owner, Fred, prices fairly, checks in daily, and can sometimes fit a job in sooner than expected.

  • Kitchen cabinets and islands, interior walls, ceilings and trim, drywall repair, porch staining, exteriors, small commercial jobs
  • No storefront listed on Google; it says it serves Fishers, Carmel, Geist, Westfield, Noblesville, Pendleton, McCordsville and Anderson (per its Facebook page)

How we picked

  • We started with the painting companies that show up on Google Maps for Fishers searches, then kept the ones in Fishers, elsewhere in Hamilton County or on the Indianapolis northeast side.
  • To make the list, a company had to be independent and locally owned (no national franchises), rated 4.7 or higher on Google with at least 50 reviews, and have no BBB grade below A- if it has a BBB profile. When a company has several Google listings, we used the one closest to Fishers. We also left out a listing where many recent reviews read as near copies of each other.
  • We ordered them by Google rating adjusted for review count, so a 4.9 from 700 people counts for more than a 5.0 from 12. (We blend each rating with 100 reviews at 4.5 stars, so small samples don’t jump to the top.)
  • We read about 30 recent Google reviews for each company and summarized the themes that came up more than once. One-off complaints aren’t counted as themes.
  • Ratings and review counts were checked on November 16, 2026. They change daily, so click through for today’s numbers. We recheck this list every few months.

Before you hire any house painter

  • Ask for proof of liability insurance. Indiana doesn’t have a statewide license for house painters to look up, so insurance is your main protection.
  • Get the quote in writing, with the rooms or surfaces, number of coats, paint brand and line, and what prep is included.
  • Ask whether the company’s own employees or subcontractors will do the work, and who to call if something’s wrong.
  • For exteriors, ask how they handle rotted wood: is replacement priced in, or billed once they find it?
  • If your home was built before 1978, ask whether the firm is EPA Lead-Safe certified before it sands or scrapes old paint.
  • Check your HOA’s color rules before you pick an exterior color. Many Fishers neighborhoods require approval.
  • Ask what the warranty covers and how touch-ups work after the job.

Questions people ask

Which Fishers-area painters paint kitchen cabinets?

Bays Painting’s reviews are mostly about kitchen cabinets. The Painting Edge’s reviewers mention kitchen and bathroom cabinets and a sprayed vanity finish, and DutchPopp reviewers mention painted vanities. White’s Painting has a reviewer who had kitchen cabinets done along with the exterior.

Will a painter fix rotted trim before painting?

Several on this list do. Guy Painting and Onit Painting reviewers describe rotted cedar trim and siding replaced before the exterior was painted, and White’s and DutchPopp reviewers mention rotten trim boards swapped out first. Ask whether that work is in the quote or billed separately.

Why isn’t my favorite house painter on the list?

It may not have met one of our cutoffs (4.7+ on Google with 50+ reviews, locally owned, no BBB grade below A-), or we may have missed it. Tell us about it using the link below, and we’ll look at it when we recheck the list.

Run a house painting company in Fishers? Tell us about your business. Getting on this list is free and follows the rules above. Separately, you can become the labeled local expert behind one of our guides.