A good mechanic explains the problem before touching the car, puts the price in writing and doesn’t push work you don’t need. These seven independent shops in and around Fishers have strong Google reviews, and for each one we read the recent reviews and wrote down what people actually say, good and bad.
Our 7 picks at a glance
- Alderman Automotive Service Center: clear explanations, plus Saturday hours
- Esler’s Auto Repair: a shop to stick with for years
- Reggie’s Motorworks: European cars
- Euro Motorworks: a second opinion on a dealer quote
- The Noble Mechanic: rides home while you wait
- Professional Automotive: quick oil changes and photo inspections
- Clark Tire Fishers: tires and brakes, from cars to tractors
Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.
1. Alderman Automotive Service Center
Best for clear explanations, plus Saturday hours
What reviewers say: Reviewers keep saying the service advisor walked them through the recommendations and the price before any work, with no pressure. Getting in on short notice comes up often, along with oil changes, A/C repair and same-day pre-purchase inspections. Many reviews thank the same front-desk staff by name.
- The service center of Alderman Automotive, a family-owned used car dealer in Fishers (per its Cars.com listing)
- Open Saturdays 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., weekdays 8 to 6 (Google)
- On Trade Center Dr in Fishers
2. Esler’s Auto Repair
Best for a shop to stick with for years
What reviewers say: Honesty is the word that comes up most, and a lot of reviewers say they’ve brought every family car here for years, one for 20. People say the staff won’t push work you don’t need, explains things patiently to people who don’t know cars, and is good at tracking down a problem. Rides to and from the shop come up too.
Good to know: A couple of reviewers wanted more status updates on longer jobs, and one felt the prices were close to dealer prices.
- BBB accredited since 2009 (BBB)
- Reviewers mention brakes, transmission flushes, throttle and sensor repairs, engine work, oil changes and pre-purchase inspections
- Based on Tournament Trail in Westfield
3. Reggie’s Motorworks
Best for European cars
What reviewers say: Most of the reviews are from owners of BMWs, Mercedes, Audis, Porsches, Volvos and VWs. Reviewers say it found problems other shops couldn’t, kept them updated throughout, and didn’t push extra work. A couple mention a loaner car or an Uber ride home, and prices that beat the dealer.
Good to know: Two recent reviewers paid diagnostic fees and still didn’t get their problem fixed. Ask up front what diagnosis costs and what happens if the first repair doesn’t solve it.
- Reviewers mention electrical diagnosis, suspension, alignments, oil leaks, maintenance and pre-purchase inspections
- Weekdays only; Google lists Monday hours with a lunch break, noon to 1
- On S 10th St in Noblesville, next door to The Noble Mechanic (pick 5)
4. Euro Motorworks
Best for a second opinion on a dealer quote
What reviewers say: Reviewers describe the shop explaining what the car needs, and what can wait, before doing anything. A few came for a second opinion and found a much cheaper fix than the dealer quoted, or a leak the dealer missed. Loaner cars and a free car wash come up again and again, and many reviewers have been customers for years.
- BBB accredited since 1998 (BBB)
- Works on European cars and Lexus (per its website)
- On E 90th St near Castleton, on the Indianapolis northeast side just southwest of Fishers
5. The Noble Mechanic
Best for rides home while you wait
What reviewers say: The shuttle comes up a lot: reviewers say the shop drove them home or to work after drop-off, or paid for an Uber when the driver was out. People also mention being kept in the loop with options and prices, and getting worked in within a day for brakes, timing belts and other repairs. Several say the staff showed them the problem on the car.
- Focuses on Asian and American vehicles (per its Facebook page)
- Reviewers mention brakes, timing belts, diagnostics, small electrical fixes and pre-purchase inspections
- On S 10th St in Noblesville, next to Reggie’s Motorworks, with a second shop in Kokomo (per its website)
6. Professional Automotive
Best for quick oil changes and photo inspections
What reviewers say: Fast oil changes, often 30 minutes or less, come up again and again. Reviewers like the written report with photos of anything that needs attention, and say the staff doesn’t push repairs you don’t need. A couple expected a big suspension or engine bill and got off with a few hundred dollars. The clean waiting room gets a lot of mentions.
Good to know: Weekday hours only (Google lists Mon–Fri 7:30 a.m. to 5 p.m.). Its Yelp rating is much lower than its Google rating.
- Identifies as veteran-owned (Google)
- Oil changes, brakes, suspension and scheduled maintenance such as timing belts, plus alignment, exhaust and transmission service (per its website)
- On E 86th St near Castleton, on the Indianapolis northeast side
7. Clark Tire Fishers
Best for tires and brakes, from cars to tractors
What reviewers say: Speed and fair prices are the big themes: flats patched first thing in the morning, and brake jobs dropped off one day and done the next. Reviewers bring everything here, from family cars to dump trucks, RVs, tractors and zero-turn mowers. Several call it an honest, old-school local shop.
Good to know: Weekday hours only (Google lists Mon–Fri 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.).
- Tires, flat repair, tire pressure sensors and brakes, for passenger, commercial, farm and lawn equipment
- On Reynolds Dr in Fishers
How we picked
- We started with the auto repair shops that show up on Google Maps for Fishers searches, then kept the ones in Fishers or close by in Hamilton County and on the Indianapolis northeast side.
- To make the list, a shop had to be independent and locally owned (no national franchises or multi-state chains), rated 4.7 or higher on Google with at least 50 reviews, and have no BBB grade below A- if it has a BBB profile. We left out collision and body shops.
- We ordered them by Google rating adjusted for review count, so a 4.8 from 1,000 people counts for more than a 5.0 from 12. (We blend each rating with 100 reviews at 4.5 stars, so small samples don’t jump to the top.) When ratings were close, we leaned toward shops in Fishers.
- We read about 30 recent Google reviews for each shop and summarized the themes that came up more than once. One-off complaints aren’t counted as themes.
- Ratings and review counts were checked on November 16, 2026. They change daily, so click through for today’s numbers. We recheck this list every few months.
Before you hire any auto repair shop
- Get a written estimate before any work starts, and ask the shop to call you for approval if the job grows.
- Ask what the diagnostic or inspection fee is before you drop the car off, and whether it goes toward the repair. Several reviewers on this page were surprised by it.
- Ask to see, or keep, the old parts they replace. A good shop won’t mind.
- Ask whether the technicians are ASE certified, especially for engine, transmission or electrical work.
- Ask what the warranty covers, for parts and for labor, and for how long.
- For a big repair, get a second opinion. A few reviewers here saved thousands that way.
Questions people ask
Which Fishers-area auto repair shops are open on Saturday?
Of the shops on this list, only Alderman Automotive Service Center lists Saturday hours on Google (8 a.m. to 4 p.m.). The other six are open weekdays only, so plan a weekday drop-off.
Where should I take a European car near Fishers?
Euro Motorworks’ website says it works on European cars and Lexus, and its reviewers drive everything from Minis to Land Rovers. Most of Reggie’s Motorworks’ reviewers drive BMWs, Mercedes, Audis, Porsches and Volvos. Reviewers at both mention loaner cars.
Why isn’t my favorite auto repair shop on the list?
It may not have met one of our cutoffs (4.7+ on Google with 50+ reviews, locally owned, no BBB grade below A-), or we may have missed it. Tell us about it using the link below, and we’ll look at it when we recheck the list.
Run an auto repair company in Fishers? Tell us about your business. Getting on this list is free and follows the rules above. Separately, you can become the labeled local expert behind one of our guides.