Fishers has plenty of pizza, but most of it comes from national chains. These are five independent or Indiana-owned pizza places with a Fishers address and strong Google reviews, from wood-fired pies to a lunch buffet. For each one, we read the recent reviews and wrote down what people order and what they say, good and bad.
Our 5 picks at a glance
- Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub: a family pizza night
- Spice & Bites Hub: chicken tikka pizza and late-night food
- Passione Wood Oven Pizza & Wings: wood-fired pizza and wings
- Chicago’s Pizza Fishers: the weekday lunch buffet
- Maestro Pizza and Market: halal pizza
Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.
1. Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub
Best for a family pizza night
What reviewers say: Friendly, attentive staff come up in almost every recent review, often by name, and families say it’s an easy, fun place to bring kids. Two reviewers were surprised with a birthday dessert. Reviewers keep ordering the breadsticks and filling up at the salad bar, and a couple mention it tastes like the Noble Roman’s they grew up with.
Good to know: Its Yelp rating (3.6) is far lower than its Google rating, so recent visits may be better than older ones.
- In the Fishers Station shopping center on Allisonville Rd
- Open daily, 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. and until 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday (Google)
- One of 12 Noble Roman’s Craft Pizza & Pub locations, all in Indiana. Thin or deep-dish Sicilian crust, gluten-free and vegan options, an endless salad bar and a self-serve root beer tap (per its website)
2. Spice & Bites Hub
Best for chicken tikka pizza and late-night food
What reviewers say: This is a pizza place and a Pakistani and Indian kitchen in one, and reviewers mix both in the same order. They praise fresh, made-to-order food and warm, welcoming owners, who are named in several reviews. On the pizza side, reviewers keep ordering the chicken tikka pizza and the calzones. From the rest of the menu, biryani, chicken karahi, butter chicken, garlic naan and halwa puri come up again and again.
Good to know: A couple of reviewers called it a hidden gem that was quiet when they visited. It has fewer reviews than the other picks, so it got in under our lower review minimum (see below).
- On Fishers Landing Dr on the west side of Fishers
- Open daily, 11 a.m. to midnight (Google), the latest hours on this list
- American, Pakistani and Indian menu, with pizza deals such as a family meal with a 16-inch pizza, garlic bread and wings (per its website)
3. Passione Wood Oven Pizza & Wings
Best for wood-fired pizza and wings
What reviewers say: The wood-fired oven is the draw, and reviewers describe a light, crispy crust and fresh toppings that remind some of them of Italy or the East Coast. The wings get almost as much love as the pizza. Reviewers keep ordering the wood-fired wings (sweet chili and buffalo come up), the Detroit-style pizza and the bruschetta, and friendly servers are named often.
Good to know: Closed Mondays. The dining room is small, and a couple of reviewers had long waits or a cold garlic bread. Its menu page lists 4 to 9 p.m. hours while Google shows 10:30 a.m. opening, so call ahead for lunch.
- On Brooks School Rd on the Geist side of Fishers
- Tuesday to Sunday, until 9 p.m. (10 p.m. Friday and Saturday), closed Mondays (Google)
- Pizza from a Pavesi wood oven, plus Detroit-style pies, homemade baked ricotta and locally made gelato (per its website)
4. Chicago’s Pizza Fishers
Best for the weekday lunch buffet
What reviewers say: The lunch buffet is the big theme: fresh pizza that keeps coming out, salad and dessert pizza included, at a price reviewers call a real deal. Staff are described as friendly and thoughtful. Reviewers keep ordering the breadsticks with cheese and using the salad bar, and it gets mentions for kids’ birthday parties too.
Good to know: Closed Sundays, and Monday hours end at 3 p.m. One reviewer said the buffet line can get pushy at busy times.
- On Market Square Dr in north Fishers
- Monday 10:30 a.m. to 3 p.m., Tuesday to Saturday until 8 or 9 p.m., closed Sundays (Google)
- One of more than 20 Chicago’s Pizza locations, all in Indiana. Deep-dish, thin crust and traditional pizza, a salad bar and a party room you can rent (per its website)
5. Maestro Pizza and Market
Best for halal pizza
What reviewers say: Several reviewers call it the best halal pizza around, and they describe kind, generous owners and staff. Reviewers keep ordering the merguez pizza, the Philly cheesesteak and the fried chicken. While you wait, there’s a small grocery section with olives, olive oil and other pantry items.
Good to know: The space is small, with a couple of outdoor tables, and one reviewer said it’s better for takeout than eating in with kids. Another said the fried chicken depends on who is cooking.
- On E. 141st St in north Fishers
- Open daily, from 11 a.m. (9 a.m. Sunday) until 8 to 10 p.m. (Google)
- Pizza, Philly sandwiches, fried chicken and fish, with online ordering through its website
How we picked
- We started with pizza places that show up on Google Maps for Fishers pizza searches, and kept only those with a Fishers address that are currently open. Places Google lists in Indianapolis, Carmel or Noblesville didn’t count, even when they’re close by.
- To make the list, a pizza place had to be independent or Indiana-owned (no national or out-of-state chains or franchises) and rated 4.5 or higher on Google. We started with a minimum of 150 reviews, but only four places passed, so we lowered it to 75 reviews. That let in Spice & Bites Hub.
- We ordered them by Google rating adjusted for review count, so a 4.7 from 2,000 people counts for more than a 5.0 from 20. (We blend each rating with 100 reviews at 4.5 stars, so small samples don’t jump to the top.)
- We read about 30 recent Google reviews for each place and summarized the themes and dishes that came up more than once. One-off complaints aren’t counted as themes.
- Ratings and review counts were checked on November 16, 2026. They change daily, so click through for today’s numbers. We recheck this list every few months.
Before you go
- Check the closed days. Passione is closed Mondays, and Chicago’s Pizza is closed Sundays and closes at 3 p.m. on Mondays.
- Want pizza late? Spice & Bites Hub is open until midnight every day, according to Google.
- For a group or a kids’ party, Chicago’s Pizza rents a party room, and Noble Roman’s has a salad bar and root beer tap that kids like.
- Passione’s dining room is small, so on a weekend night, expect a wait or order ahead for pickup.
Questions people ask
Where can I get wood-fired pizza in Fishers?
Passione Wood Oven Pizza & Wings on Brooks School Road bakes its pizza in a Pavesi wood oven, according to its website, and reviewers keep bringing up the oven and the crispy crust. Its wings are finished in the same oven.
Is there halal pizza in Fishers?
Yes. Reviewers of Maestro Pizza and Market on 141st Street repeatedly call it their favorite halal pizza, and the merguez pizza is a common order.
Why isn’t my favorite pizza place on the list?
It may not have met one of our cutoffs (4.5+ on Google with 75+ reviews, a Fishers address, and independent or Indiana-owned), or we may have missed it. Tell us about it using the link below, and we’ll look at it when we recheck the list.
Own a pizza spot in Fishers? Tell us about it. Getting on this list is free and follows the rules above.